Distant Aliens & Space Dinosaurs with Lisa Kaltenegger

Unidentified Speaker
All things finance and economics are usually discussed at Startalk radio. But have you heard about doublenomics? It's okay if you haven't because Startalk radio likes to keep you in the know and it's extremely niche. Here's an example of double nomics. Discover automatically doubles the cashback earned on your credit card at the end of your first year with cashback match.

That means with Discover, you could turn $150 cashback to $300. It pays to discover. See terms@discover.com creditcard this episode is brought to you by Progressif, where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average. Plus, auto customers qualify for an average of seven discounts. Quote now@progressive.com to see if you could save progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates.

National average twelve month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states and situations. So, Matt, after that conversation, I'm ready for life to be discovered on exoplanets, like tomorrow. I mean, I'm gonna need lunch first, and then I think we're good to go, right?

Matt Kirshen
I'm excited. I'll feed you and then we'll learn. About life in the universe. No, just a salad and a salad. You know, we've been learning a lot about methane and stuff.

I don't want anything too big. Okay? All right, me too. Looking forward to this. Life in the universe.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Finally with the methods, tools and tactics to figure it out and the James Webb telescope lending its hand, coming up on startalk. Welcome to Startalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. Startalk begins right now. This is startalk. Neil degrasse Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist.

I got with me as today's co host, Matt Kirschen. Matt, hey. And I have you in person. I know, I know. It's been so long since I saw you knot through a screen.

Matt Kirshen
Yeah, like it's real. You can put post it notes on my actual face rather than just covering it on the screen like normal. Oh, is that what I do? I imagine. Well, welcome to town.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Welcome to my office here. It's lovely to be back at the. Hayden planetarium of the American Museum of Natural History. I mean, that's always exciting. It's fun to come to work.

Matt Kirshen
Does it get old? I hope it doesn't ever get old. The fact that you walk through the natural history museum to get to work. It never gets old. When I pass little children seeing exhibits for the first time.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And I just remember when I was a kid, the awe with that same experience. Yeah, the natural one. Plus, if you come through at night, yeah. Don't tell anybody, but all the animals come to life. I've tons of rumors.

Matt Kirshen
I've heard them. It's really true. So today is gonna be a cosmic queries, right? And it's on, I think, everybody's favorite subject, the search for life in the universe. Now, most people just talk about it, but some people have invested research time trying to figure this out.

Some people have actual expertise in it rather than just expertise. Maybe that's what I'm actually saying here. Rather than people like me just looking up at night and going, ah, it's gotta be something, right? So I have with me Lisa Kautenegger. Did I say your name correctly?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Koutenager. Perfect. And it's so much fun to be here. And Neil, I have to tell you, even so, it's the small kids that do the wonder when I walk through those doors, I'm back at being the small kid and just like, kid again. And I do want to know if at night the dinosaurs come alive, because I'm here.

Lisa Kaltenegger
We're just going to record until night because I want to see that. You don't want to leave. You don't want to leave. No way. So you.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I have your. A brilliant background here. First, you're an astrophysicist, but more importantly, you're an astrobiologist. So there's a whole bio side of you and any biology I know, it's like I have to pick it up on the side. But here is centerline with you.

And you're associate professor of astronomy at Cornell University. Who else was at Cornell? Somebody else. I don't know. Was there anyone?

Rhymes with Fagan is a Reagan. Let me just kind of someone involved. In, like, some communication as well as research. Anyone who wrote books. And there's this cool office on the third floor where misses Kaltenger is sitting right now.

Lisa Kaltenegger
But it was the office that rhymed with Fagan. Oh, so it's who got Carl Sagan's office. There's an answer to that. Me, me, me, me, me, me, me. Wow.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So I was. No pressure. I was in that office 50 years ago. Wow. 49 years ago, I was in that office.

Lisa Kaltenegger
You know what? If you come back and be in that office, just think about what's going to happen, and then, oh.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Sorcery will you be. So what you have to do is get your office set so that we can reprise what he did. Okay. I'm in his office. And he reached back, did a no look, reach behind him.

No look reach. Pulled out a book that was one of the books he wrote and then handed it to me, signed it to me. So you gotta have all the books that you wrote on that shelf. And then my shelves are, like, all hickory, like, I have, like, books piles. So I'm gonna just pull one and then the whole thing's gonna.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Yeah. I feel like if I tried that, I'd somehow pull the bookshelf onto me. You are director of the Carl Sagan Institute. Absolutely. And like I said, the answer to the question who got Carl Sagan's office and your research interests?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
You model habitable worlds. I'd say the great thing right now is we know of more than 5600 worlds around other stars, other suns, if you want. You know, of course, their name is not sun but it's cool when you look up and you know that around every fifth one there's a planet that's at the right distance so not too hot and not too cold and a rock so small enough. And so it could potentially be a habitat, as you said. And so we live in this time where, with the James Webb space telescope, big telescope we put into space, for the first time we can catch enough light to figure it out.

So why does the light tell you that there might be life? So the light is a cosmic traveler and the great thing about it is it's actually encoded information in it. That's how astronomers know how the universe works. Yes. We don't know anything without that.

Right. That's very true. If it's dark, you can't go there. You can't put it in a petri dish. Even so, I do have to say the engineer should do a bit more work, right?

Lisa Kaltenegger
I've seen this on Star Trek and Star wars. Like, they can do it now. She wants them to go to the stars as well. You heard it here first. Engineers.

Matt Kirshen
You're all lazy. Every engineer. I'm just saying, abandon the other stuff. All pull together and make me an Enterprise. Right.

Lisa Kaltenegger
I would like to go to these cool stores we found, okay? Do you want to upset this fine scientist? Engineers, it satisfies at all. Okay, but you know what? The thing is like I'm even doing the blinky eyes.

If somebody gets me starship Enterprise, I will do that. I can do that if that's what it takes. All right. All right. So in the light, what's encoded there that is of value to you.

So, basically, when you have light, what we do as astronomers is called spectroscopy. We split it up in its colors and we figure out if all the energy gets to us, or if some of the energy hit the molecule or atom before it got to me. And thus, even so, I can set foot. I cannot set foot on these planets, yet I can actually figure out what's in the ear of these other worlds. Okay, so because each chemical, each molecule has its own characteristic absorbing pattern, right?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Yeah. Okay, exactly. It's like a barcode. And if you think back to high school, like, each chemical has a different structure, like water. H two O has an oxygen atom and two hydrogen ones.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So it looks a little bit like a triangle, nearly. And oxygen, two oxygen atoms, looks different. So the energy that needs to hit it, to make it swing and rotate, needs to be different. And light carries energy. So which one's missing tells me, like a stamp and a passport, what chemical is in the air of this other world without me being able to get there.

What's kind of nearly as cool as stark. So what are you specifically looking for? What things are you hoping to find or expecting to find? So what we're looking for is when you look at the earth and try to figure out if this life on the earth, the combination of oxygen and the reducing gas, like methane, tells you that something is producing oxygen, methane, in huge amounts. So reducing means you take an oxygen away from where it once was.

Exactly. Okay. Reducing basically means it reacts with oxygen and it will steals it. It steals it, absolutely. It's a good stealer.

And so it makes CO2 and water. So if you see it together in the atmosphere of a planet, you need two sources that produce it. And for methane, could be life, but also could be volcanoes. What you're saying is that the methane and the oxygen, when left alone, are unstable and they will disappear unless somebody's. Cranking it out continually or something is cranking it out.

Exactly. Just love each other. Think about this. They love each other so much that they will actually dance and go and make CO2 and water. So by them being together in the atmosphere, you can actually figure out that that's a fingerprint of life as we know it.

Matt Kirshen
Oh, because if it still exists, if it isn't disappearing and you don't have a volcano that's causing it. So for the methane, the volcano could do it, but for the oxygen, with the methane, the oxygen needs life to do it in those big quantities. But if it's just oxygen, it's not enough, because you could think about the long time. Like, our planet's been around for 4.55 billion years, right? So if you had one oxygen ever so often, let's say one oxygen atom a week, then it would build up.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So you need the methane to grab it. Did you say one per week? If you had one or one per month, you're 4.5 billion years. You can accumulate it. This is why you need the methane.

This is why it's key to have the reducing gas. Other than that, it could just build up and you wouldn't know where it comes from. Did you put all that in your book? I did. Alien Earths, the new science of planet hunting in the cosmos.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Ooh. And so the cool thing that when I think about these alien worlds, like, some of them could be like ours, so they could be habitats, as we just talked about. Hence alien earths. Not just alien aliens. No.

Lisa Kaltenegger
And theres an s at the end because the other way is also think about it that way. When you look at our own planets through time, you wouldn't be able to say you on the earth if you were a time travel. So that doesn't work. Like Einstein show we can go back in time, but if you could, you would not be able to figure out it's the earth and probably not, you know, statue of liberty hands sticking out or something to tell you. Wait, the Statue of Liberty shows up in every science fiction movie I know.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So you know it'll be there. Yeah. So what would be their equivalent on other planets? Is this one of the things that you research? Like, if they don't have the same kind of, like, hominid shape to their bodies, like, their statue of liberty would look weird to us.

Matt Kirshen
I do have to look normal to them, but, yeah, it could be like. Lobster with a claw still. But still holding a torch. A claw holding a torch. Yeah, exactly.

I figure it would still have a torch and a crown, but, like, it would be maybe two crowns if it's got. Depends on how many heads it has and how many. But I think the good thing is, like, think about it might be easier to spot if it's like three legs or five legs. We only have one arm. Like, how did they do it?

Lisa Kaltenegger
This one arm stuck out. Wait, wait. So, Lisa, how biased are you? How biased are we? I think we as scientists, and you know, Neil, you also were thinking about life in the universe at one point, right?

So I think we biased, but in a good way because we have to be ultra conservative to tell you that we found life. We don't want to just make it up. And so what we do is we look for something that we cannot explain other than with life, and keep our eyes open for things that are interesting, weird and unexplained in terms of chemical makeup of a planet or some kind of features, like art, space art that blocks out some part of the starlight. So lots of ideas are coming in, but we have to be concerned to find it for sure. And then we have to have an open mind for something we don't know what to expect yet.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And this is all because we can't actually see the surface of the planet to see if there's cities or people or whatever. So you gotta do the secondary way to get in on there. Absolutely. But what's really cool is the next generation of telescopes that we're planning right now. The habit of world observer, for example, supposed to be really big so that you actually can block out the stars light, see the tiny, tiny planet next to it, and catch the light from the surface.

Lisa Kaltenegger
And thus, you know that you said about the biology and my name. Right. And my professional description. I actually have a biolab where we grow, grow life in all the different colors from all different parts of the world, like deserts, like ice fields. Did she just say she creates life in her biola?

Matt Kirshen
She grows it. She grows it. She grows it. No, no, no, no. You know, I'm just verifying.

I mean, you've never seen my kitchen, but we've been growing life there for a while as well. I'm not proud of it. The bottom shelf of the refrigerator. Yeah, yeah. There's some different colors.

Lisa Kaltenegger
There's all different colorful ones. Send them out. All right, I'll. Chuck. Give me an address.

Matt Kirshen
Give me a mailing address. Can I ask you, if someone like your equivalent on a different planet, on a different star had a telescope pointing at Earth, what would be the markers of life that they would see from us? That's exactly the question I had about two years ago. And with an amazing person here at the American Museum of Natural History, Jackie Faharty. We actually went to figure that out because we know where the stars are.

Lisa Kaltenegger
There's an amazing mission called Gaia that's up there right now that is having a look where all the stars around us are. And we're like, where would we be, the aliens? And so we figured out that if you just have our level of technology, that means you need to have the planet go in front of the hot star. So you see the star ever so slightly being less bright for the Earth. That would be once a year for 12.8 hours.

Then there are within 300 light years, so light from there to us. And the other way around, about 300 years, there are 2000 star systems where we could be the alien and people could be wondering, ah, hopefully they're not bad aliens there. We're pretty bad aliens. They won't think there's life here unless they can see the statue of liberty sticking out of something. We're sending it out.

I'm wrongly hoping that they also figured out that the gas combination will work, because that lets you say that there's life on our planet for about 2 billion years. And that's how I got started in the field, because I was part of the design team to build such a telescope to try to find other life on other worlds. And we were looking for 21% oxidizers deaths right now, modern Earth. And I was like, but the earth changed, right? And then people said like, well, yeah, if you think that's important to figure out, do it yourself.

And I was like, very young and naive. I was like, oh, you can do this. Then I figured out how hard it was to do so. Nobody had done it before. And this is why we figured out it was 2 billion years.

And, you know, 4.55 billion years of history on the earth. But for half of it, think about it. For the 24 hours clock since lunchtime, you can actually spot signs of life on the earth. And so, in a way, the news is out of the bag if they just figured out our level of intelligence. And I'm having high hopes that there's more out there than just our intelligence at all.

Exactly. We redefine it. We reflect physics on what you just said. I think technically, if you want to be physics precise, it's not that methane and oxygen are signs of life. It's that methane and oxygen are signs of something out of equilibrium.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And life itself is out of equilibrium. Maybe we need to be more creative about other things that could be out of equilibrium other than life. Is anyone thinking that way? What's really fascinating, and that was where, like, in 65, they started out with this combination of oxygen and methane, right? So it's like old school thiamine.

Lisa Kaltenegger
65, sorry, 1965. That the Miller Urey experiment went around that time, too. The idea was then they said, well, it's just disequilibrium. But then we actually figured out that geology is super good in making disequilibrium. And sometimes life actually brings an atmospheric chemistry back to equilibrium.

So there's only some very specific pair of gases that in disequilibrium would actually only be explainable by life. And so that's like new, right? Because you'd say, like, okay, 1965. They figured it out, right? We've done stuff since then.

Even so, we haven't found life yet. But it's fascinating. This search tells us so much more about our planet two. And how it works and how life works. So before we go to q and a, because this is a cosmic queries, one question before we hand it over to you, Matt.

Matt Kirshen
I'm in. I'm ready. You collected the questions from. They're from our Patreon members. And there's.

This is, unsurprisingly, this may not be a shock, but this was one that brought in a lot of questions. So I'm going to try and get through as many as I can. Of course it would. Why wouldn't. This is a.

This was a big issue. I'm excited. Okay, so let me just ask. What is life? Ooh.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Such a good question. And a whole chapter in the book and no answer. Oh, it's a blank page. What is life? It's just a shrug.

Matt Kirshen
It's just a picture of your shoulders going on. How are you shrugging? Yes, it's really, really great. Because as an astronomer, I actually don't need to know what the basic tiny definition of what life is. Cause I need a biosphere that changes my whole planet for it to spot it somewhere else, around another star.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So, in a way, I've put all the knowledge we have together, you know, that it basically can evolve, that it's Darwin evolution, that it has information content and so on and so forth. And that's an entity that's encapsulated. So I put everything together from biology, Nobel Prize winners and other people I talked to. That one I didn't talk to, I actually read his book. But I talked to the other people who do biology in the Carl Sagan Institute.

And they're like, yes. No, no. Yes. So I distilled. That's a good sign.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
It means it's a vibrant field. It's a vibrant field. So I distilled everything I know. And then I did put a blank page for your work here. Did you?

Oh, my gosh. We were just joking. Yeah. Isn't that right? Is it?

Matt Kirshen
I'm gonna be honest with you. I don't think my version of my work here is gonna be much help to the field. But some other people might. You never know. Some other readers of your book might take that bat on a run further than I can.

I think mine's more likely to be a shopping list. Right. Here we go. And the first page is pretty cool too, because it has alien wannabes. Oh, yeah.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Life on earth. That would. If you would show it to me, right. Without DNA testing, I would be like, oh my God. And of course here is the tardigrade.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Oh yeah. Stuff on earth that looks alien, basically. Absolutely. And that survives things that it kind of. You don't know why it survives.

We know it's desiccation for the tardigrades. But, you know, if you would sell it as like an alien, you'd get pretty far. Until desiccation means you remove the water. You remove the water, leave it for dead. Yes.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And it just doesn't care to re. So here's the page where you draw on your own planets and life. I gave you a couple of planets, but you can start your own ideas here. Very thoughtful. See, this is what I want in a science book.

Matt Kirshen
I want facts and information, but I also want doodling space. A couple of good cartoon doodles. Yeah. And the really great thing is like when you write your own book, you can do what you want to a certain extent if you sell it. That's right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's right.

Unidentified Speaker
You can save every day by shopping at Whole Foods Market. Seriously, dont just go for the big sales. They have literally thousands of low priced goods with their house brand 365 by Whole Foods Market. While at happy prices, limited time, seasonal flavors and all the quality you expect, like no high fructose corn syrup or over 300 other ingredients banned from from all the food they sell. There's so many ways to save at Whole Foods Market now you know.

Whether you're a family vacation traveler, business tripper or long weekend adventurer, Choice Hotels has a stay for any you. And that's good, cause there are a lot of me's. Choice Hotels has over 7400 locations and 22 brands, including comfort hotels. Radisson Hotels and Cambria hotels get the best value for your money when you book with choice hotels. Cambria Hotels feature locally inspired hotel bars with specialty cocktails and downtown locations in the center of it all.

Hey, that's me. Radisson hotels have flexible workspaces to get the most of your business travel and on site restaurants. That's me too. And at comfort hotels, you'll enjoy free hot breakfast with fresh waffles, great pools for the entire family and spacious rooms. Hey, that's me too.

I guess I'm just gonna have to stay at all of them. Choice Hotels has a stay for any you book direct@choicehotels.com. where travel comes true. Summertime, summertime, some, some summertime. You know what that means.

Its time to break out the grill. And no matter whats on the grill, best foods is making sure this summer is one to savor the rich and creamy best foods, you know, and love comes in even more irresistible flavors. A bit of spicy mayonnaise gives a meal a nice kick. Made with real peppers for real spice lovers, if you're not afraid to be bold. Garlic aioli made with real garlic adds irresistible flavor to every dish.

And it even works great as a dip. Deliciously flavorful. 100% best foods find spicy mayonnaise, garlic aioli and even more exciting flavors@bestfoods.com.

i'm Nicholas Costello and I'm a proud supporter of startalk on Patreon. This is startalk with Neil degrasse Tyson.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So, Matt, bring it on. Given that you've just brought up sea creatures and other creatures on Earth that look alien, Craig Caldwell from the UK, from my home planet says, wait, it's. My home planet, too. Oh, the UK is not a planet unto itself. I mean, we're still, as we, we have an ego.

Matt Kirshen
We have an ego. Then I'm saying that. Yeah, but not in New York City. Are you going to get away with saying that? Okay, go on to.

So Craig asks, how possible is it that life has landed on Earth from a meteorite and has just become another animal? And he says, I'm pointing at the octopus here, but not exclusively. Oh, I love that. Love the shot. Octopus don't look like nothing else on.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Earth, and I've seen them land in the movie arrival, so, you know, they kind of look octopus like. Octopus. Right, right. But the cool thing about this, if you think about where they could come from and people think about Mars or other planets, actually, the earth had the best bet so far because it had watered the longest on a rocky surface. So the question is more like, if we were to find life on Mars, maybe we're going to find out they're actually earthlings that became martlings.

But of course, it sounds cooler if we might be marshlings or some other things would be. Did you say the word Marslings? Well, I did. We didn't we invent the word for that already? Martian.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
There's a movie called Martian. I know, I know. Nobody calls Matt Damon Marsling. Well, that's why you're the scientoid. This is the key song that we haven't found life on Mars.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So I can't say Martian. So I say Mars Lane just a hypothesis. Okay. But the cool thing is, like, if there were kind of different life, we would find out if we do our sciency thing, where we basically check everything and see if the DNA is made out of exactly like everybody else, DNA chemistry wise. Right.

Then you don't get away with calling it aliens, because for an alien creature, you'd hope that at least one chemical pair is going to be different to tell us. Right? Because it seems quite unlikely that even if life's on another world, what I hope that it is exactly the same chemistry it will use. Why is that unlikely when if you talk to geologists, they see that similar minerals on other planets. Absolutely.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Why do they get to have the same rock formation process? But you are not going to recognize that. Maybe biology is universal. I think biology is universal. I didn't want to say that.

Lisa Kaltenegger
What I mean was like, carbon scaffolding and water are probably really, really good basis for life. But what nuclear pairs you could have taken for the DNA, you have so many options. Or for proteins, there aren't so many options to make minerals. Oh, gotcha. And so I think this is why.

Because it's going to be so weird when, for example, we'd find it on Mars, right? Would it have been a hitchhiker we brought if it looked exactly like the Earth? Or is it life doing the exact same thing under different environments, down to the tiniest atom? I bet everyone would bet on the hitchhiker. Well, this is why we're going to the icy moons and hopefully just fly through the plume.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I see moons of Jupiter, right? Jupiter and Saturn, so that we don't contaminate those environments. And this is why the whole departments of NASA, whose job it is to make sure we don't do that contamination. Right, exactly. It's a job.

Lisa Kaltenegger
But it's so hard to do, because life, very hard to kill. Good thing. It's a good thing. Yeah, you should say that with like a. She's trying it.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I've tried to kill her. So frustrating. I've got so many hammers tried fire. There's nothing. That's what she does most of the time in her lab.

Lisa Kaltenegger
But the coolest thing is actually, if you think about life on the Earth, you would actually have to melt our planet to about 10 km down to actually limited life, because there's life down to about 10 km that deep. And so if you just get rid. Of life on Earth, this worries me. Does it worry you, Matt? How do we auto clave on?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Here's how you get rid of life on Earth? Melt it down to 10 km. Cause we now know there are these extremophiles, right? That can survive in like volcanic or tardy rays, right? Yeah.

Matt Kirshen
So you can't just sort of. You can't just boil Earth for two minutes. I think about it as more hopeful, because even if we were stupid enough, and I hope we're not, to actually destroy all of ourselves. Destroying life is luckily so much harder that some other kind of bug might actually make it to the stars, if we can. Plus, if you look at the extinction episode record, maybe we should be amazed we're all still here.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
There's a 90% extinction episode, the PT extinction, Permian Triassic. And then there's the famous one, the KT extinction. We lost 70% of species. I mean, the universe had been trying to kill life on Earth like for years. And here we are doing a podcast.

Lisa Kaltenegger
I really this cool wonder that we hear, and then we can actually figure out the secrets of the stars, right? We can do that. I actually think we should give this much more wonder and credit. And thus, like kids seeing exhibitions for the first time, look at the stars anew, we figure out what they are. Like, the majesty of it all.

Matt Kirshen
So Torsten Diekov from Berlin says it took evolution quite a while to develop multicellular life on Earth. How likely is it that most planets are populated only by bacteria or similarly simple life forms? Also, great question. So this 2 billion years of oxygen and methane combination gives you a range of life. What we don't know is how fast evolution could be on another world, because we have only a sample of one ours.

Lisa Kaltenegger
But we think with more and more oxygen, you get more and more complex life. Just think, dinosaurs. There was more oxygen in the air, actually, when the dinosaurs were around, thus big creatures. And so right now, we're 2020, 1%. What was it back then?

We think 30 to 32. And so the coolest thing is, like, Jurassic park, worlds would actually be easier to spot than us. And so we published this was pretty funny. And then the headlines were like, alien dinosaurs. I'm like, whoa, whoa.

We didn't talk about alien dinosaurs. You can't put those two words in a title and have the press properly interpret it. But having said that, I saw it differently, because if we now get everybody who loves dinosaurs to also love exoplanets, they have to, if we're looking for. Alien dinosaurs, right, that gives us 100% of all kids. And I think that's exactly what we need to get to the SARS.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I feel like, we're stealing them from the anthropologist and the paleontologist, but I'm okay with that. Wouldn't they learn so much more if they had other dinosaurs on other planets? Yes, they would. See, it's just like, we're helping out. Yeah.

Matt Kirshen
I mean, that is a way to get kids into science. Kids love space. Kids love dinosaurs. Dinosaurs in space. There it is.

Lisa Kaltenegger
And then if we tell them that, you can go and talk to comedians who do funny things and be on the air and say, hi, mom. Right. You know, what else is there that they would want? Maybe these superpowers. But, you know, if you were on one of these other moons, like Titan, because it has so much less gravity, but a dense atmosphere, you could flap your wings and you could actually fly.

On Titan, you couldn't breathe, but you could fly. Yeah, you suffocate. But other than that, everything is fine. Everything's fine, right? It'd be easy to fly.

Matt Kirshen
You're saying a great 60 seconds or so as you chokingly fly in a panic. You could also come with a spacesuit. I'm not saying you can't do that. So what's the gravity on Titan then? It's just much less than here.

Yeah. Maybe it's a third moon, is one 6th Earth, so it'll be no more than half for sure. I think it's somewhere around a quarter. Yeah, sure. What do you weigh here on Earth?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Pounds? Dude, this is America. I have no clue about pounds. 120? Yeah.

Yeah. So on the moon, you'd weigh 20. Pounds of just think about how high you could jump. And thus we have all the kids back. We have superpowers.

Lisa Kaltenegger
We can give them. Damn. You want to give them superpowers? Dinosaurs and space, what more do you want? Be kind to others, your fellow scientists.

Matt Kirshen
It does look fun bouncing around on the moon. I mean, that feels like. The funny part is when you see the astronauts skipping. Right? That's what I show my students when I teach.

Lisa Kaltenegger
I'm like, look, this is real life skills. If you ever find yourself on the moon, you know that you have to skip. And skipping. Kids stop skipping, like in middle school. Yeah, you shouldn't do that because you might find yourself on the moon at one point.

Matt Kirshen
Yeah. Do they have to have skipping classes in NASA in training? I think they do. They do skip underwater. Is it part of selection?

Lisa Kaltenegger
I don't know that. Neil, do you know that? Have you ever tried out for an astronaut? No. The underwater is just for zero g, not for low g.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Right. But did you ever try out for the astronaut program and actually tried to figure out if you had to skip. No, no, I never did that. I never did that either. So, Matt, you have to go and become our token astronaut to figure that one out.

Matt Kirshen
I mean, I think I'm still a good skipper. I think I can still skip to it. Decent level. All right. But you will have to do it for the ESA, right.

Lisa Kaltenegger
The european space agencies, who will have to figure out about the american system. Well, how does it work? Because I'm on my way to getting citizenship, so I might be able to. Do my straddle both citizenship. Can I get the two patches?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay, why not? Why not citizenship? Science is international, so that must be. Invited to the launch. All right, it's a deal.

Matt Kirshen
You heard it here first. So there's a couple of questions about different types of life form and different environments. Victor Ray Rutledge from Texas says, can there be entities, say life forms, which exist outside of any planetary boundaries? And then Jono from Iowa also says, what are the extremes of environmental conditions that we think life could exist in and we look for across the galaxy? I'd like that.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So that would include planetary moons, maybe asteroids, comets, or just free floating in space. Are these legit places? I think it's really great. So the first ones are absolutely legit places. So there's no reason a moon couldn't be a habitat or maybe even asteroid, even though there becomes a bit tricky because it gets really cold.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So you have to dig down deep, and in the moon and a planet, you have residual heat from being actually formed. So you could do that. So the moon doesn't have heat left over from being formed, but Earth does. Right. Right, Earth, sorry.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's all they heat down under the mid ocean ridge and all these places. Exactly. And the other moons in our solar system, around the giant planets, they are actually being molded. So the other moons actually tuck on them, as well as Jupiter or in the other system, Saturn. And so there's tidal heat that gets generated, so they actually get warm.

Lisa Kaltenegger
And this is why we have oceans. We have tides on Earth that move in and out, and we credit the sun and moon for that. So you're saying we have tides on moons of Jupiter and what effect does that have on the. Absolutely. So we have tides on moons of Jupiter.

And so what it does is basically we have these ice balls because it's so far away from. Right, it's outside the Goldilocks lock zone, but because of this pulling and pushing that actually deforms those moons. There's heat that melts the ice under the ice shell on top. And so we know those ice shells actually swimming in liquid oceans. And so this is where we high hopes that maybe those oceans could also have kind of life.

And so this is what we can do. No shortage of life in our oceans. No, that's a sensible thought, but it's. A very different ocean. So this is why we're sending things there to investigate.

Oh, because it's much smaller and it gets bent out of shape. And hopefully the bent out of shape has been since forever. But for some of the moons, they are a little bit smaller, like Enceladus that goes around Saturn. And so it's a very not so deep ocean. But we think it has been around for millions of years.

But the question is, has it been around for billions of years? And how long do you need an ocean to get life? And so I completely hijacked that question. So, yes, yes, life actually has some boundaries, as we know. It's when you destroy the cell walls and when you make it so hot or irradiated so much that everything breaks down the structure, that basically lets you concentrate chemistry in the inner part of the cell.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I like the way you're saying that. So I do know that molecules are held together by certain binding energy and if exterior to the molecule, there's more energy than that available. Just bust up the molecule. Exactly. And we are complex molecules.

So if you, so you don't want to get busted up. You definitely don't want to get busted up. And it's actually even earlier because you need the cell walls because those allow you to get some chemistry in and some out. And so if you were swimming in a huge ocean, one of the key problems you have is to concentrate the chemistry enough to get something like DNA and RNA started, because you need concentration for that. The frequency of them bouncing into each other.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Exactly. And the ocean is vast and if there's like a couple of molecules, when are they ever going to meet? Right, right. And the other thing is like when it gets too cold, we think these reactions are starting to be so slow that it might take so long for any of them to take place. So there are some limits on life, but so far we think you need, at least for starters, a rocky surface and some water where you can concentrate the chemistry and make these kind of vesicles that become cells.

And then wherever you find those conditions, hopefully. But one of those questions was we went how many? Three and a half billion years with single celled life. Is that somewhere around there? Right?

Absolutely. And the key point is, that's a long time. That's a very long time. But there's two good things. So there are stars that are older than us, and planets are as old as their stars.

There's a star that's older. Well, that was older than the earth is now, when the earth formed, and it has planets. But also we have no idea what sets the evolutionary clock. And so it could be faster evolution or slower evolutionary. All I'm saying is it seems to me, Lisa, that if Earth went three and a half billion years with single celled life, it could easily have gone another three and a half billion years.

And this is why this lifely discussion is so helpful in science, where people actually are now coming to the conclusion, or at least that's the best explanation we have right now, is that if you have enough energy available, and that was the oxygen content in our air, then you will make more and more complex life. And it's not completely done yet, but that's the best explanation we have for now. So get oxygen. So if you sneak some oxygen in early enough, we might have had our explosion of complex life sooner in the timeline of the earth. That's basically what the biologists are telling me.

And so at that point, because I'm an astrophysicist, even an astrobiology leaning one, my knowledge gets a little bit less, less complete. So I talk to people, but it kind of makes sense. If you had energy available that life could easily use, you could become more complex. So the life becomes opportunistic. Absolutely.

Opportunistic is, I think, a great word for life. So there's a kind of related question about the environment from Kevin Vale from Chester, New Hampshire, who says, I've always wondered how massive of a rocky type planet would carbon based life still be possible? How much higher or lower gravity might affect life? And so that's a great question. So, generally, gravity should mostly affect the structure.

Let's assume everything's equal. You have a rocky, solid surface and you have some water. So then gravity affects your structure. You need enough pressure on top of your ocean not to evaporate the whole thing. Right.

So you need that. So, chemically, what you're saying is if there's this vacuum above the water, there'd be nothing to keep the water in its liquid state. Exactly. You need the pressure of the air in order to maintain that. Okay.

Completely. Right. My in laws live in Colorado. It's high altitude. Trying to boil something.

Matt Kirshen
Yeah, water boils off pretty quickly. You dry out very quickly, and that's a fraction of a vacuum. Right. Right. Or you could have an ice layer, like in the icy moons.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Right. That basically keeps your water below protected. And so how small can you get? As small as you allow me to have liquid water in a rocky surface. And so those moons that get tidally heated, actually, from the first principle, without the tidal heating, they would be too small because everything would be frozen and cold.

But because they're tidally heated and physics works in the whole cosmos, you basically get this additional liquid water. So what's too small depends on the circumstances. Do you get pulled and pushed from your neighboring moons? Yes or no? And so we're still learning the limits, but at one point, when it becomes so incredibly big, when it forms, it will actually grab onto all the gas that's around it, and it will become one of these big planets, like Jupiter or Saturn.

And so at that point, we don't know how you could have liquid water with a rock interface with not super critical liquid water because there's so much pressure on it and so hot. You make an interesting point. So the more massive the planet, the more likely it would have retained gases that in Earth's history or Venus's history or Mars history would have been long lost into space. Absolutely. So when we think about this, really, it's like, why does the planet have an atmosphere?

And it's not the whole story, then it's really the pull of gravity that the planet has versus the escape velocity, how fast you need to. The molecules of the air, the molecules in the air. So there's no such thing as a jumbo, rocky planet. Rocks? We don't think so.

And so that's the really interesting thing, again with the James Webb space telescope, because what we found most of the planets, I've had thousands of planets, right? One out of five maybe, like ours. 200 billion stars in our galaxy alone. Billions and billions of possibilities. Even so, of course, he never said it.

But what's really interesting here is that the most common planets are some we don't have. They are bigger than the earth and smaller than Neptune. So these super earths, great name. Whether theyre better is absolutely not clear. How are they like, this is what were now figuring out.

We dont know from first principles. We have some ideas, but the James Webb space Telescope lets us look and confirm those. You did say billions and billions. The man wrote a book called billions and billions. I know, after everybody kept saying it.

And then he went onto the show, right, and said, okay, now I say it officially. Do you know who first said billions and billions. Who did it was Johnny Carson. Johnny Carson. Right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
From the Tonight show. But he basically interpreted as saying that Sagan said it, right. Yeah. He was imitating Carl Sagan in an exaggerated way. He knew he said billions and he said it.

So in a fun way. You gotta double up on it. Billions and billions plus. There was a cartoon where it was like Carl Sagan as a child says, look at all the stars. There must be hundreds and hundreds of them.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Perfect. It's part of pop culture. In 1976, Carl Sagan published a paper with Ed Salpeter speculating on life in Jupiter's atmosphere. Until now, you've only been talking about rocky surfaces, and he was imagining predator, prey, a combination of life forms that could sustain themselves without any care at all about the surface of anything, like balloons that had buoyancy, these flying creatures living off the temperature gradients within the atmosphere. Is there much thought still given to that idea?

I love that paper just because it shows the creativity that you need at the edge of the forefront of science. But we have learned more and more about the original life since then. Luckily, science always learned it was 50 years ago. It was 50 years ago. Visionary paper.

But what we've learned so far is that you need a rocky surface and some kind of water to get this chemistry going to start it. But maybe you can't just have molecules come together floating around, convecting air cells. The chances that they're going to stick to each other and make a kind of cell are just so small, even if you give it 4.5 billion years. But having said that, once we have such floaty things, we could always bring them to Jupiter and reenact Carl Saganda. And then Saltpeter's amazing paper.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That'll be our atmospheric zoo. Wow, there's some kid watching that. That's your task. That's your 50 years from now. That's gonna be your job.

Lisa Kaltenegger
That sounds great. I wanna be a zookeeper there, too.

Unidentified Speaker
Immerse yourself in captivating experiences you can enjoy anywhere with the Nintendo Switch system, whether you're at home or on the go. Reconnect with familiar characters in Mario Kart eight deluxe. Or explore vast and epic worlds like the Legend of Tears of the Kingdom and Hogwarts legacy. No matter where you are or what you're doing, you can turn anytime into playtime with Nintendo Switch games and systems sold separately. Games rated e to Taideh.

Your new beginning starts now. Doctor Horton has new construction homes available in Ellensburg and throughout the greater Seattle area. With spacious floor plans, flexible living spaces and smart home technology, you can enjoy more cozy moments and sweet memories in your beautiful new home. With new home communities opening in Ellensburg and throughout the Seattle area, Doctor Horton has the ideal home for you. Learn more@drhorton.com Dot Doctor Horton, America's builder and equal housing opportunity builder who doesn't.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Love a classic chocolate chip cookie? Famous Amos has been making them since the seventies, 1975, to be exact. With semi sweet chocolate chips and a satisfying crunch, it's everything classic in one bite sized cookie. And fans couldn't get enough. That's right, you'll find our original recipe, the one you know and love, in every bag of famous Amos original chocolate chip cookies.

Find famous Amos anywhere you buy your favorite snacks.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So what else you got? Well, we've been dancing around this question and this, this idea a little bit, so let's just ask it directly. This is from Gavin Traber from Sacramento, soon to be Doctor Gavin Traber, RNA biochemistry and molecular medicine. Ooh, go for it. And Gavin wants to know, do you think the origins of human life on Earth, or at least the basic building blocks, such as amino acids, came from the stars already formed from elsewhere?

Matt Kirshen
Or were they originally synthesized in a prebiotic Earth? So let me, let me offer a version of that question back at you. Okay? You guys always talk the talk. When the amino acids are discovered on meteorites being delivered from space, you talk to talk.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay? But Earth is made of all these same ingredients. Why do we need any ingredients from space at all if the birth ingredients of Earth has all of those ingredients all by itself? I really think it's more the glamour from everything that comes from space, because you can make the chemistry down here, too. But it's kind of cool to find it on an asteroid or meteorite or another moon, right?

It's got a cool factor. I think it has a coolness factor. Or even, anyway, tonight, necessarily know which one's which. Yeah, like, how would we know where that this amino acid that became at. That point, we need the Tardis.

Lisa Kaltenegger
You, me and Neil have to go in and then get back to that point. Tardis. A doctor who's Tardis? Not just to the right time, but to the right location. This is why I want the Tardis, right?

Because it gets you to where and when you want to be space and time and figure out how life started here on the earth then. Wait, wait. I think I know the answer to this, though. Go ahead. Many amino acids have a chirality to them, where they are different in a mirror from what they are in real life.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So there's a certain configuration of the atoms that is just not symmetric in a mirror. Am I right in thinking that one way is good and the other way is evil? One has a goatee here. Yeah, that's how we tell. That's how you tell.

Lisa Kaltenegger
That's how you know one way is good and the other one is just blah. Like one is your favorite food and the other one is blah. So the amino acids that would have chirality on meteorites are 50 50. And all the ones on earth, are they left handed or whatever is the handedness. So all life has only one handedness, but the ones from the meteorites have both.

Exactly. So, but the key point is that did you need to bring them to the earth so life had enough to eat? So the theory would go that, you know, if we starting out and we didn't have life yet, we probably had 50 50. And it's quite interesting that there are some researchers who say that it could have gone either way. Yeah, but life just picked one and that's the one it picked.

And what's really fascinating too is that when we trying to make life in the lab and we can't do that yet, that's the problem. Right. We don't know how life started because we can't do it in the lab. And so to all the amazing colleagues, because before that you said, I don't like engineers, I love engineers. Married to one.

But basically just to say it is really hard to make life in the lab and what you would want to do is you would want to make it with a different chirality. So you know you're making it from scratch and that's so hard to do. But when the life escapes the lab. You tried to tries to kill. We know which ones to kill.

It's not going to kill you because you oblah. Right. It doesn't want to eat you. It can't digest you. It's a safety measure.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
But I bet if it's chasing you down the street, it won't know until after it's in your stomach that it couldn't digest you. That's evolution. And we have like billions of people, so hopefully just don't be the one that it eats. 1st. 1St, right.

So we got time for like one more. Okay, well, I like this question from Eduardo Lobato from Spain, but living in Finland, but asking the question in English. And Eduardo says, does the discovery of dimethyl sulfide on planet K 218 B by the James Webb make us rethink how probable life is in other worlds. And also what makes DM's a marker of life. So what's really interesting once.

Let's back up for a minute. So, K two. That's one in the Kepler's catalog. Is that right? Okay.

Lisa Kaltenegger
K 218 b. Right. It's not like the other peak. Yeah, the other mountain. We've just discovered it.

Matt Kirshen
We've discovered life on that mountain. Yes. A climber. It's a dead climber. It used to be alive.

His name was Bentley. He had feelings and found it. Oh, no. Come on. Okay, so can we survive?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
This is catalog id. K two. Keep going. K 218 b. 18 b.

Okay, so now tell me about this molecule. So basically it's DM's, dimethyl sulfur. And on the earth, life makes it. But now we have these other planets. We were just saying, these super earths and mini neptunes, we don't understand the geology, we don't understand the photochemistry.

Lisa Kaltenegger
So even if we see gases that on the earth, in a chemistry like ours, would actually indicate life, you have to be very careful not to misinterpret it. And that specific case is interesting because it tells us something new about these weird worlds we don't have in our solar system. We definitely try to think about ways that life could be there. But if you have so much gravity, you would have kind of a super critical ocean under huge amount of hydrogen. And on the earth, the bacteria that makes DM's needs light.

And so there it would actually be dark. And so, absolutely, we're thinking about this a lot. How do you deduce all of this from just the James Webb data, from. The spectroscopy, from basically looking at the light. And so what's really important about these discoveries that they make?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
It feels almost voyeuristic. Yeah. Flying on you. Do these bacteria mind us? Well, this is the question, right?

Lisa Kaltenegger
We haven't asked for the consent of spying on other potentially alien worlds, but we're doing it very kindly. No interaction, we just looking. And then if we find something interesting, you know, I was about to say, but we don't know the laws there. So it's not just the engineers, it's also the lawyers who have to get up to speed. Right, right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So it's intriguing. This planet is bigger than Earth, but not as big as Neptune, is that right? So it's bigger than ours, but not as big as Neptune. But the key point is it will be so different from the earth that you shouldn't just go with the same conclusions. When you find something that would indicate life on the earth, and that's what we're learning.

Lisa Kaltenegger
The more interesting planets we find, the more patterns we will see, and the more we'll learn about geology, photochemistry on these other worlds, what we just don't know because we never had one of. Those scenarios, earth like planets, then you'd feel more confident, oh, my God. If it were an earth like planet, I would be so much more excited about it. But if you have a mini Neptune with a huge hydrogen atmosphere, no light hitting a potential ocean, we don't even know if the ocean is there, then I'm just saying. Maybe intrigued, but not sold yet.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
There it is. I like that. Intrigued, but not sold. All right, we got to end on that note. That's a very hopeful note, I think.

I think the wonder, a curiosity stimulating note that you just ended on. I think what's really great is that we live in this time where, for the first time, we could figure out if we're alone or not, and all of us get to live in it. So that wonder that we all bring to looking at the night sky, childlike wonder. Childlike wonder. We could point up count to five, say one out of five might have.

Another earthen, but one out of five of the stars. Stars might host another earth, but maybe in a couple of years, we could say, oh, that one. That one shows signs of life, and. Then you realize that that one's actually just a plane flying over the airtime. That shows signs of life.

Matt Kirshen
It does have signs of life and. An Elon satellite that's going across. Right. Oh, my gosh. Lisa, thanks for coming to town.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Thanks so much for having me. This was fun. And congratulations on the book, Alien Earths. You know what? Somebody called Neil degrasse Tyson said it was good.

It's on the back cover. Whoa. Yeah. Who's that guy in the blurb? Let me see.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Let me. Hang on. Let me just see what that says. There is that top blurb on the list? Of course.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Top. It's my duty, if I'm asked to blurb a book, to make the shortest blurb possible, it's still informative, and that usually ends up at the top. Lisa Kaltennager's breezy narrative style invites you to experience with her the challenges and joys of being a scientist on the frontier of discovery. Who said that? Who said that?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Right there. Some guy. Neil. Neil degrasse Tesla. Who is that guy?

Lisa, congratulations on the book. Thanks for coming through town. Thanks so much for having me. And next time I come to your office, we have to reenact some Carl Sagan things. Absolutely.

Lisa Kaltenegger
I think it's gonna be this year because it would have been Carl Sagan's 19th birthday. You should come. We should sit there and we both should think about what he'd wanna do now. All right? We'll work something out, I promise.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And, Matt, good to have you here in person. Joy, look at this. Look at this. Real. Real.

Lisa Kaltenegger
Can I do that, too? Yeah. Matt exists. He's not a bot. It's real.

Matt Kirshen
I'm not some avatar. Yeah. And he's very happy. He sat in the middle of us. That's what I came here for.

I came here for the physical touch. We've been lacking it. It's really a facial. That's how you should think about it. A facial massage and keep that podcast going.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Probably science. And I finally remembered it correctly. You got it dead on. Probably science. All right.

All right. After this interview with Lisa Kaupeneggeregh, I'm reminded, explicitly reminded, that the best scientists out there are those who are still kids. What does a kid do? They turn over rocks, look behind trees. They're curious about everything.

Everything. Because the whole world is a frontier to them, a frontier of exploration. If you carry that into adulthood, then the universe is there for you to reach out and explore, discover. And you have to pick up some math along the way so that you can speak the same language that the universe does. But when you do, oh, my gosh, what a joy it is to be a child again.

Not many adults get to make that claim, but those adults on the frontier who are scientists do. That is a cosmic perspective. Until next time, start. Talk. Keep looking up.

Unidentified Speaker
Your new beginning starts now. Dr. Horton has new construction homes available in Ellensburg and throughout the greater Seattle area. With spacious floor plans, flexible living spaces, and smart home technology, you can enjoy more cozy moments and sweet memories in your beautiful new home. With new home communities opening in Ellensburg and throughout the Seattle area, Doctor Horton has the ideal home for you.

Learn more@drhorton.com Doctor Horton, America's builder and equal housing opportunity builder earning your degree. Online doesn't mean you have to go about it alone. At Capella University, we're here to support when you're ready, from enrollment counselors who get to know you and your goals to academic coaches who can help you form a plan to stay on track. We care about your success and are dedicated to helping you pursue your goals. Going back to school is a big step, but having support at every step of your academic journey can make a big difference.

Imagine your future differently at capella.edu.

Distant Aliens & Space Dinosaurs with Lisa Kaltenegger

Primary Topic

Episode Summary

Main Takeaways

Episode Chapters

1: Introductions and Sponsors

2: Setting the Stage for Astrobiology

3: The Role of Telescopes

4: The Science of Spectroscopy

5: The Search for Bio-Signatures

Actionable Advice

About This Episode

People

Companies

Books

Guest Name(s):

Content Warnings:

Transcript