Cosmic Queries - Physics All Around Us

Progressif
This episode is brought to you by Progressif, where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average. Plus auto customers qualify for an average of seven. Discounts now@progressive.com. To see if you could save progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates national averaged twelve month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary.

Discounts not available in all states and situations. So why do you want to learn a new language? I'll tell you why. Because donde esta el Bano? Can be a very important question at times.

Rosetta Stone
You know, Rosetta Stone is the most trusted language learning program available on desktop or as an app. Fast track your language acquisition with immersive lessons designed to teach you to pick up languages in a natural way. I love the fact that I can go from my laptop to my phone to pretty much anywhere and learn the language of my choice. Not to mention I'm bringing my communication skills to new heights. Don't put off learning that language.

There's no better time than right now to get started. For a limited time, Startalk radio listeners can get rosetta stones lifetime membership. For 50% off. Visit rosetta stone.com. That's 50% off, unlimited access to 25 language courses for the rest of your life.

Redeem your 50% off@rosettastone.com. Startalk today.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Coming up on this episode of StarTalk, we dig into our archives and find the physics all around us. We learn about the periodic table of elements, the asymmetries in nature, solar energy, battery technology, Maxwell's equations, and more. Check it out.

Welcome to Startalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. Startalk begins right now.

This is Startalk. I'm Neil DeGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. I hail from the American Museum of Natural History right here in New York City, where I serve as director of the Hayden Planetarium. And today we've got a cosmic queries edition of Startalk with my co host, Chuck nice. Hey, Neil.

Chuck, always good to have you. Good to be here tweeting at Chuck Nicecomic. Yes, and I am the director of parts of my home on certain days of the week, even then, only certain hours of certain days, that's all I get. So I think today is the topic is the physics of everyday life. Yes.

Yeah. Love me some physics of everyday life. I know you do. Oh man, I've been around you long enough. The physics everywhere.

Chuck Nice
I hear you speak on the physics of everyday life, whether I want you to or not. You know what's good about learning physics? Yes. It's not a satchel of fact. That's right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
To be regurgitated. It is an understanding of the operations of nature. That's great. I was about to say it is actually the understanding of your own experiences. Yes.

Or even things that are not your experience. Things that transcend your experience. True. Physics is there waiting for you. Yeah.

Chuck Nice
Yeah. That's what makes it so cool. I mean, there's. But what it means is you don't have to learn every single example of how physics manifests in the universe. Well, thank you.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
You can learn the foundational things and then apply that knowledge to what you see. Yeah. So that's the beauty of it. And that's why physics books are not the fattest books on the shelf. Accounting books are fatter than the complete works of physics.

Chuck Nice
Right. Cause they. What? They get to change accounting. You can't change physics.

Physics is what it is. It's what it is. And what it be like. What it'd be like is what it be like. But you can change accounting all you want.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
It's so many other fields where the books are just so fat and thick and books on human physiology. You gotta learn every little. Of course, there are some systems that you learn about, you know, the circulatory system and the endocrine system and this sort of thing. Right. And that's very helpful for new situations.

But physics is the ultimate example of learning the basics. Right. That then apply to everything. Stuff you've never even seen before. And even all of those different systems actually have some applied physics at work.

Oh, okay. Let me take you there. Ready? Okay. Let's do it.

So, biology. Yes. Is the extreme representation of chemistry. Interesting. Yes.

Chuck Nice
Give me 1 second. Biology is chemistry. Come alive? Okay, now I'm just about that. It just gave me a little light bulb and I got it.

That makes sense. Right? Right? Yes, yes. You can have complex chemistry, but once you talk about life, right, that's biology.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
It earned its own field. Absolutely. And life is really a collection of chemical reactions. Correct. Have you ever seen the physics desk?

Reference physicians desk, the PDR? No, I have not. It's a zillion pages. And it is every single medicine prescribable in the world, or at least in the west. Is that really.

Yes. Wow. Yes. And so when a doctor looks back and you don't see what pages they're turning, they're looking at a PDI, they're. Looking at a PDI.

So it's every company's medicine that gives what, you know, what it is supposed to heal, what the contraindications are, the side effects. All of this, it's in this book. So all I'm saying is it's a reminder that we are basically saxochemistry. Yes, but what I'm getting at is which. I mean, it sounds so derogatory when you say it like that.

Now pass me my vitamin, please. Yeah. Hey, listen here, you sack of chemistry.

Yeah, we all take vitamins or some pills for some purpose, most of us. Or we eat certain foods to get the chemistry in the food that'll, you know. You're drinking a cup of coffee right now. Yes, I am. Which was why it's having a chemical reaction in my body.

Correct. Right. It turns off a little teeny part of your brain that says, go to sleep. So there is no understanding of biology without chemistry. Yeah.

And there is no understanding of chemistry without physics. Nice. And there's a kind of audacious statement, which is really nasty, but kind of true. Okay. After the laws of physics, everything else is opinion.

Chuck Nice
Ooh, damn. Yeah. Yeah. That's a drop the mic. That's a drop the mic.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And it's kind of like, you know. Who made that saying up? A physicist, clearly, in your opinion. All right, so give it to me. We solicited these from our fan base.

I haven't seen the questions yet, as usual. As usual. So what do you have? And of course, we always start with a Patreon patron. Patreon.

Chuck Nice
Because if you support us on Patreon financially, we give you preference to what we get. More than that. It's not just. They get their question answered. There's, like a whole list of stuff.

There is. I mean, you know, one level. They get invited to our holiday party. That is correct. If you.

If you give enough. Is that right? Just verifying. Give enough money, you get to invite it to the. To the start.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Give us zillion dollars. Right. A kabillion. A bajillion. Bajillion.

That's the biggest number ever. That's the biggest bajillion. Bajillion. Mmm. That's cool if you're eight, right?

Biggest number ever. Bajillion. My God. And really, it's like eight. It's like, you know, there's 16 of them.

Chuck Nice
That's to a kid. It's like, my son. I told my son I was 30, and he was like, you're gonna die soon, right? Mind you, I'm like, much older than 30. Why am I lying to my son about my age?

I don't. Don't trust anyone older than 30. There you go. That's it. That's.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
There you go. All right, so Renee Douglas from Patreon says this. Why is the periodic table of elements not an exact rectangle? My OCD will not let this go missing. Elements or what?

Chuck Nice
Who cares? It should be a rectangle. All of a sudden, at the end, she started sounding like Jerry Seinfeld. What's the deal with the rectangle? Why?

Who are these elements? Okay. We should call it the periodic irregular table. So I'm with her on this. There's the urge to want nature to be symmetric in its beauty and beauty in its symmetry.

Wow. That sentence is symmetric. It is. Yes, it is. It is symmetric and in a mirrored way.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay, so I'll give you an example. When we were filming Cosmos, one of the scenes was in a forest in northern California night. And I'm looking at the tree. I'm from the northeast, and we don't have California trees here. Okay?

Our trees are kind of raggedy, kind of gnarly. Raggedy compared to the mighty redwoods and other, you know, they don't see the. Trouble that our trees. Our trees see a great deal of trouble here. Our trees are like.

Chuck Nice
Our trees are grizzled issues, right? They're grizzled veterans of nor'easters and hurricanes and, like, harsh winters. You talk to a tree in the northeast going to be like, I'll tell you what I've seen.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's the old tree on the front porch in the rocket chair. Yeah. Our trees are like the two trees in the two towers of Lord of the Rings, you know, just like, I remember a time long ago. Wait, slow down. You, too, sparked.

Are you talking duvets? I know that's true. For those. For the trees. Yeah, yeah.

Chuck Nice
Revwood trees are just like. They're just badass. Just like, I'm here, and nobody mess. With me because they get to grow unfettered by anything. Plus, they have fireproof bark.

Wow. You try to burn a redwood, it's like, there you go. That's sweet. Going around, you know, as you. Keep going, keep going, keep moving.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Nothing to see here. That's amazing. Fireproof. They need to make all of California out of redwood tree. Redwood bark.

Right? So here's my point. Some of the trees, and I'm not a botanist, so I can't identify what tree it is. The bark had striations that spiraled in one direction around the tree. Cool.

And I'm thinking, if nature itself were symmetric, that could never happen. These things are twisting on their way as they grow in one direction and not the other direction, and nothing else was twisting in the other direction. It means, at the molecular level, you have asymmetries in the foundations of nature. Nice. Now, here's something I read, but I'm not a chemist.

I just read this. Okay. All right. The molecule. Okay.

That you taste as spearmint. All right? If you took mirror image, that's the. Double mint molecule, but go ahead. If you take the mirror image of that molecule, make that molecule.

Chuck Nice
Right? If you write down the chemical formula, it'll be the same because the chemical formula doesn't tell you how to build it. The spirals in it, okay? It's just the same number of carbon, same number of hydrogen, same number, everything. If you build the mirror image of.

It and taste that tastes like poop. It tastes like caraway. Caraway, okay. And so this is an asymmetry in nature. You don't taste the same thing because of the mirror image of one molecule versus another.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So the universe is full of asymmetries. And, you know, our amino acids have a handedness to them. These are the building blocks of our protein. Right? So there's a left hand and a right hand.

All amino acids of all life on Earth is one handedness. Right? Okay? There is no life. That's the other.

But there's no reason in principle, why you could not make it so. Right? Yeah. Cause it's all. It would just be.

We're right handed. Be a left handed. Just the way it spirals in a mirror. Okay. I mean, the way it spirals versus what it would do in a mirror.

So. So this. It's intriguing because if you find life on another planet and it has the other, it's called chirality, then, you know, it didn't come from us. We had nothing to do with it. It had nothing to do with it.

Chuck Nice
Cause it's a different handed. It's a different hand in us. Right. Right. Wow.

So what is the. And what we're not sure about is whether if you eat the other life, right? Cause that's all we do is eat other life. Of course. Okay.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's what if. I mean, if it's not alive and you're eating it, then you're probably gonna have a little trip to the hospital. Cause it's lego. Look, the only thing we eat that was never alive is salt. True.

Chuck Nice
Okay? Everything else was once alive or derived from something that was alive. Right. Even pepper comes from. Yeah.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Pepper was a place. It's a plant. Right. Interesting. That's why salt and pepper are not really equal partners.

Chuck Nice
No, they're not. No. Salt is cheating. Pepper gave its life. Life to be on that table.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
On that table. Right, right. Salt just showed up. It just showed up for the party. Just like white salt.

Chuck Nice
No, I'm joking. That is so white as salt. Actually, there's black salt. I got black salt, black salt and red salt. There's pink salt, there's himalayan salt, and there's hawaiian salt.

Nice. It's pink salt. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Wait a minute, man. How racist are you that your salt is black?

Seriously? All right, all I'm saying. Why are you saying this? And another asymmetry in physics. Okay, okay.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Do you realize an electron is a positive charge? Yes. I'm sorry. Negative charge. Negative charge.

Negative charge. Okay, so now watch. I can draw field lines coming off the electron, and there'll be straight lines coming out. They call it the electric field lines. And that's fine.

I have a formula that describes that. Okay? Electricity and magnetism are two sides of the same coin, right? That's why we have the word electromagnetic. Electromagnetic.

That's why we have that word. Okay, so if things were symmetric, I should be able to find just a negative pole of a magnet. Just the same way I have a negative charge on an electron. But you can't. You can't.

Chuck Nice
Cause the moment you have a magnet, you gotta have two poles. Exactly. So get yourself a magnet. Bar magnet, horseshoe, magnet, I don't care. There's a plus side and a negative side.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Cut it in half. Now, you have two magnets with a plus and a minus side. Cut them in half. You have four magnets, each with a plus and minus side. You cannot cut off the negative from the positive in a magnet.

But you can in electricity. Right. That shows up in the formulas as an asymmetry in what's called Maxwell's equations. They are not symmetric. That's awesome.

And as a physicist, you gotta get over that when you first learn his equations. All right, so getting back to the woman's point, the periodic table of elements has a remarkable and profound level of symmetry in it. The reason why it wraps around to another row. Yes. And certain elements line up in columns is because the elements that line up in columns have the same mating properties with other elements.

Chuck Nice
Right? Okay? If you're. You can combine them, right? So take carbon, for example.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
We have carbon based life. If you're a science fiction fan, you'd think about silicon based life. You ever hear about silicon? Right? Yes.

Did they just pull that out of there, the ether? No. Silicon sits below carbon on the periodic table directly below it. It makes the same families of molecules that a carbon does. So they're saying, if we're carbon based life, why not swap a silicon atom in with the carbon and make all the same molecules?

And then you'd have life based on silicon rather than carbon. The periodic table of elements captures this fact in its structure and in its form. As you get to heavier and heavier elements, things get more complex. They get. And so you have entirely groups of elements that all behave in the same way.

Okay, so how you. You can't. You're gonna shoehorn them into one column. You can't, because now they're next to each other. So you have these things that spread out underneath.

There's the two. So the Lanthanide series and the. So just go back to your periodic table. You'll see these two rows of elements not sitting in with the other rows of elements, and we're still discovering elements, so. And sometimes creating elements.

Oh, sorry. And we're creating elements. We are better at creating elements than nature is. Right. Yes.

Chuck Nice
Nice. That's why. So we've got, like 20. What are we up to? Yeah.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
No, about 30 artificial elements now. Wow, look at that. And they're real. Yeah. Made electrons, protons, neutrons.

So they're sitting there. That's cool. Look at us playing God now. Well, that was a great answer to a really cool. That was a long answer, too.

Chuck Nice
Who cares? It was fascinating. That's all. No, yeah. So I'm saying we're about quality, not quantum.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So it's. If you have issues with asymmetries in nature, right. Then you're in the wrong universe. You're in the wrong reverse. Right.

Chuck Nice
But I'm sure that there is someplace in the multiverse that is just right for you, Renee Douglas. Oh, by the way, just a quick thing. Isaac Newton was a big fan of God, as everyone was in the day, of course. So it's not isolating him in particular in this regard. Everybody was a God fan back then, so he.

God, dude. Such a fan. Oh, God. What's up? Such a fan, dude.

Love your work, friend. Me? That's right. Okay, so, yeah, love your work. Right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So a lot of Newton's writings, he's extolling the beauties of nature as the handiwork of God. And in one place, he comments about the beautiful symmetry that the human form takes left and right. But he has to then say, but only on the outside. Only on the outside. Right.

Right. Because the inside messed up. Right. Yeah. There's not.

There's some things that are symmetric but. Not really your heart, where one side. Is bigger than one side and is louder than the other. You only have one liver, and that's. Yeah.

Chuck Nice
The inside of your body kind of looks like Jeff Bezos eyes. You know what I'm just saying? He's got like one tiny one and one big one. So the organs are sort of mildly symmetric. And there's a lot.

His eyes are so weird. And we're not 50% left handed and 50% right handed. No, we're not. Right. So there's some asymmetries going on.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's all I'm saying. Yeah. So he had to sort of accept that from his praise of God. Right. Because he assumed that God was his perfect.

Chuck Nice
There's a plan and gut plan, and. The plan would be symmetry. Same with the vitruvian man that is widely associated with. What's a da Vinci? Da Vinci.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Right. Right. With the man with his hand sticking out. Right, left and right centered on a circle. So the idea was your belly button.

Cause if we're divine, then our form would be geometric. So your belly button would be the center of a circle that you could trace with a compass. And then your arms extended and your legs out would further trace the circle. And this was the perfect human form. Had da Vinci ever met a human being?

Chuck Nice
No, because there's no one who heard. That he drew it, but he didn't come up with it. It long predates him. From what I've read, it long predates him. But.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So my point is, when you actually do that with actual people, belly buttons are not in the same place. People have longer arms, shorter arms. Absolutely. Relative to their height. So you want it all to be perfect because you have a philosophical urge for nature to be symmetric and perfect.

And if that's what's driving you, history tells us you're just going to get the wrong answer. So get over it. So in physics, we get over it early when we first learn math. Sweet.

Progressif
This podcast is supported by FedEx. Dear small and medium businesses, no one wants happy customers more than you do. So you need a business partner just like you, like FedEx, who understands your passion for serving your customers because they have the same commitment towards you. That's why FedEx offers you picture proof of delivery, packageless and paperless returns, as well as weekend home delivery to 98% of the US on Saturday and 50% on Sunday. See the FedEx service Guide for delivery information.

What's more, FedEx Ground is faster to more locations than ups ground. Trust FedEx for timely deliveries. See what FedEx can do for your business. Absolutely, positively FedEx. Whether you're a family vacation traveler, business tripper, or long weekend adventurer, Choice Hotels has a stay for NEU and that's good because there are a lot of me's.

Rosetta Stone
Choice Hotels has over 7400 locations and 22 brands including Comfort hotels, Radisson Hotels and Cambria Hotels get the best value for your money when you book with choice hotels. Cambria Hotels feature locally inspired hotel bars with specialty cocktails and downtown locations in the center of it all. Hey that's me. Radisson Hotels have flexible workspaces to get the most of your business travel and on site restaurants. That's me too.

And at comfort hotels you'll enjoy free hot breakfast with fresh waffles, great pools for the entire family, and spacious rooms. Hey that's me too. I guess I'm just gonna have to stay at all of them. Choice Hotels has a stay for any you book direct@choicehotels.com where travel comes true hey remember when we did that show about the science of the golf swing? Well lets take that to the next level.

And thats because PXG has developed the Black Ops driver so golfers dont have to sacrifice distance for forgiveness. And the science proves it. PXG Black Ops driver is a breakthrough in driver technology. Its a complete and total victory in golf club engineering unlike anything youve ever seen before. Black Ops drivers are adjustable to deliver a combined MoI of 10,000 plus for unreal forgiveness.

That's ridiculously high. The higher the MoI, the more forgiving the club will play so you don't have to square the ball perfectly for it to go straight and get distance. Add PXG's new advanced material face technology and you get incredible ball speed that pushes the distance to the absolute limit. More forgiveness, more distance, no sacrifices. PXG Black Ops driver hit your tee shot straighter and farther.

The proof is in the science. Learn more and get free shipping on all equipment. Go to pxg.com startalk and use code startalk at checkout. That's pxg.com startalk. Use code startalk for free shipping on all equipment.

Pxg.com startalk code Startalk. I'm Jasmine Wilson. And I support startalk on Patreon. This is startalk with Neil degrasse Tyson.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Chuck, I'd love me some physics of everyday life. Yeah, man, so do I. Yeah. Yeah. This is really good stuff.

Okay, so what do you have? Let's jump. Right. Bring it right back. And this is Raphael Katabak from Facebook.

You've been practicing shocking brain? Not at all. No. All right, what do you have? I mean, it probably says Smith there, as far as I know.

Chuck Nice
But anyway, if we were visited by a more advanced alien race, what do you think they will admire most about humans? And with regards to our current scientific knowledge and understanding, what particular theory or law do you think they might disprove? Oh, interesting. That is a very. That's a great question.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
I'd like that. So it would have to be, if I may be cynical. Cynical. May I? Only with your permission.

Rosetta Stone
Go, please. I'm all about. It's rare that I see you actually admit to being cynical. I think aliens more advanced than us would be impressed how far we've come. From being such dumbasses.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
For being such dumbass. For being such dumbasses. You were trying to find out a very diplomatic way how far we've come. In spite of ourselves. Exactly.

Chuck Nice
That's what I said. I think they would have said, we never thought you'd get there. Oh, that's hilarious. Cause you all been on earth for thousands of. You've had what you call civilization for thousands of years.

Wow. And it took you 10,000 years of civilization before you even visited the moon. You could have been there a long time ago. Right. But let me just be happy with.

What you did achieve. Oh, my God. Oh, my God. What? Imagine if we'd landed on the moon 2000 years ago.

No, I'm imagining right now. Imagine if the Romans had rockets. Yeah, but no, I'm imagining right now just where we were. Imagine if the Egyptians said, let's leave Earth. Well, they did.

They were aliens. Well, that's true. They were born. I saw Stardict. Stargate.

There you go. Right, exactly. They had a wormhole, so we can't really. But anyway, no, think about it. Look at all the technology that we have right now.

And if we were to take all of the energy that we put into trying to destroy one another and keep one another from advancing one, and we were to take all of that energy and just pour it into humanity. Not pure physics energy, intellectual, intellectual, you. Know, the political energy that we spent. That we expend a cultural, political and financial capital that we have used to destroy one another. Exactly.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Imagine. Just take that. Imagine. And it was all pointed at the propulsion of the human race in a positive direction. You want me to quantify this?

Chuck Nice
Oh, sit up. You ready? You've been thick about this. You ready? Go ahead.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay, in today's dollars, you know what it costs to go to the moon in total? No, I don't. $100 billion. Who are you? Doctor evil.

Chuck Nice
Doctor evil. $100 billion.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay, so we went to the moon on $100 billion. The entire us interstate system is $100 billion. Wow. Okay. 100 billion is one six.

A single year's allocation of the military budget of the United States. All right, that's disgusting. It just is. Ugh. It just is.

Chuck Nice
You should have never told me. I used to judge that, but I stopped judging it. You know why? How can you not judge that? I'm gonna tell you why.

Please. You should be judging that. I'm gonna tell you why. Okay? You tell me.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Cause I'm telling you. That's deserving of judgment. I'm telling you. Okay, okay.

What are we, in 6th grade? I said it first. So where does the budget come from? It comes from Congress. Where does Congress come from?

Chuck Nice
It comes from. We vote for Congress. So what does it mean? What does it mean? That's very funny.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's what I'm saying. As an educator. My God, I gotta stop judging it now. That's what I'm saying. Ugh, dude.

The collective representatives of the electorate allocates this money. Oh, my God. And they all agree to it. Rafael, you sent us the most depressing question ever. Wait, but I didn't finish answering.

I think they'll be happy. Yeah. We would have been on the moon 4000 years ago. It would have been like cavemen. Next.

Chapter two. Right. We would have been on the moon just going. Fire. Right.

Chuck Nice
Rock. Yeah. Okay, that's a b. I think they would be impressed with our engineering ingenuities. Okay, so.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Cause that's not the laws of physics now. Cause they would know all the laws of physics that we know. Absolutely. And then some. Oh, by the way, the laws of physics is not later shown to be false.

When we demonstrate a new theory of the universe, it's because it has been experimentally verified multiple times by competing factions. And we say, this is how it is. We're moving on from here. Okay. What can happen is you have a deeper understanding of the world that encompasses this smaller understanding that you have that works.

That can happen. It happens all the time. All of newtonian physics got subsumed into einsteinian physics. But Newton is not all of a sudden wrong in all the regimes in which it was tested. So I think they'll say, not that you're wrong.

Oh, you think this is the full story? There's a bigger story. You got the big bang starting the universe. No, we got multiple bangs. We have higher dimensions.

We got this, we got that. And you're just one little cog in this much larger wheel. That would be highly enlightening for us on a scale of learning. This is an unheralded point of discovery in the history of my field. In the 1920s, 1920, the year going into 1921, we did not know where the spiral fuzzy things in the night sky were.

Just spiral fuzzy things in our galaxy or entire other spiral galaxies in the universe. Wow. There are people alive today who were alive before we knew that our galaxy was one of only 100 billion in the universe. So the idea that you're not alone in some concept, we've been hit with that multiple times before. So the astrophysicists, we'd be ready for it.

We'd love it to death. But there's some people who are happy with their contained knowledge of what is and is not. Exactly. But does it have to get over it? Don't make me think about something other than what I.

Other than what I already can think about and already can grow. I've actually accepted this. This correct. Excellent. So let's go to.

Chuck Nice
Okay, I'm gonna read this anyway. Kevin Miller from Facebook wants to know this. Assuming the earth is flat. Big assumption, Kevin. I just love any question that starts.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Off with, all right, let's go there. Let's go there. But I know you're. Let's follow. The reason.

Chuck Nice
One of the things I like about you is that you'll take these and do something with it. All right. When the ice melts at the poles, where is all the water going to go? I have no idea. Exactly.

Cause the earth ain't flat. No, it seemed to me it was spill off the edges. Edges, right. I mean, seriously, if the earth were flat, it'd be like a table, you know? So, yeah, you spill some on a.

Table, goes off the edge. Yeah. I'm thinking, unless you build a dam. Ah. So now the earth is not flat.

It's more like a pie dish. Oh, yeah. It's got edges to it. It's got edges. And beyond there be demons.

Why do I feel like Jack Sparrow right now? Beyond their. Beyond thar limits. All right, well, there you go, Kevin. There you have it.

All right, that's. It's a pie plate. It's a pie plate, bro. That's all we can do for you. Let's move on to Nader's.

19 872 from Instagram. How far away would a black hole have to be in order for our solar system to fall into it? I also have another question. Why are you so awesome? I love star talk, and you are just one of my heroes.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's that. He just. That last part was for me.

Thank you, Tri. Did he really say that? Yeah. I'm serious. He was talking to you.

Chuck Nice
I was joking. Yes. He's saying, you are one of my heroes, and I really love startalk. Okay. No, we appreciate that.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And let the record show that you were reading that question, whether or not he appended it with that sentence. Well, he didn't write it to me. You don't know the questions. We don't boost questions up just cause you're not saying nice things. Well, we do boost questions up if you're saying nice things about Chuck.

Chuck Nice
Nice. Because I'm the one who's reading the damn question. So thank you for those kind words. Okay. Now, the question after the kind or actually preceding the kind words was how far away would a black hole have to be in order for our solar system to fall into it?

I think what he means, instead of how far. How close. Yeah, yeah. Have to be as the same thing. Same idea, same thing.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So that's not how black holes work, right? Okay. Black hole is not some giant sucking machine where you're like, my career.

Chuck Nice
Oh, I'm sorry. I'm laughing at my own. We love you, Chuck. Okay, Chuck, you're a hero on our podcast. No matter what else is happening to your career.

I don't know. No matter how far in the toilet your career may be. Chuck, did you get booed off this comedy stage last night? No, actually, really good show. Good show.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Very nice. Very nice. So anyway, it does. Should a comedian be the one who judges whether the comedian has a good show? No.

Chuck Nice
Yes. The comedian is always the one who judges. Because here's the great thing about being a stand up comedy, okay? Oh, you know. Yeah, you always know.

And you can. You can. And I love young comedians. Cause they get off the stage and they immediately lie to themselves, you know, and they get off the stage and they look at you and they go, yeah. So that felt good, right?

And I'm like, why are you asking me? It felt good. It felt good. You don't need my permission for it to feel good. You know you suck.

You know you suck. What is your problem, chuck the mentor?

No wonder no one comes to me for advice. All right. Anyway, back to native 19872. Black holes are not some giant sucking machine. Okay?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
So they have a gravity commensurate with their mass, like anything. You have gravity? Yes, I do. The moon has gravity. Earth has gravity.

The sun has gravity. Anything with mass has gravity. Anything with mass or energy has gravity. Cause energy and mass are the same equals. Right.

You can ask how much mass does. How much mass does the black hole have? And if it has a planet's worth of mass, it could just hang out in our solar system like another planet. Right. If it has a star's worth of mass, it might accrete planets to orbit it.

If it has. Interesting. So it could even have a galaxy's worth of mass. A galaxy's worth. We have a supermassive black hole in the center of our galaxy.

So you don't want to get too close to it because there are places where there are no longer stable orbits. Then you fall in. Then you fall in. You can calculate what that distance is. And it's not too hard to stay away.

Chuck Nice
Right? It's not that hard. Right. If we turn Earth into a black hole, it'd be like the size of a plum. Last I calculated so.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And it would send it and the moon would still orbit it. The moon would fall. It wouldn't fall in. Wouldn't care. It's only responding to the mass and the gravity that it.

So what makes black holes interesting is that you can get really close to them and get ripped apart and spaghettified. Okay. You can't get closer than Earth's surface to Earth's center of gravity. Okay. Okay.

You'd have to shrink Earth to get closer to it. Shrink it down to a plum. Now you've been spaghettified. Wow. So all the interesting stuff that happens with black holes is because you can get really close.

Otherwise you're hanging out where you always been. You were perfectly safe. Don't have nightmares about it. It doesn't do anything to this. Like, it never.

Now, if I had Earth as a plum, if I took another planet, take Venus, made a black hole and brought it here and let go, it would fall through the earth and eat Earth swiss cheese style as it bounced back and forth. And it would systematically dine upon all the physical contents of the Earth until Earth plus Venus became one. A big. Right. So you'd have the merging of those two.

Yes. And it become like the size of an orange or something. So the black hole would actually increase in size itself, physically. Physically, the physical black hole would increase in size. If you were to merge two black.

Holes, it turns out to be linear with mass. So a black hole that's twice the mass will have twice the diameter. Wow. Turns out if you do the math. Okay, cool.

And the diameter is the diameter of the event. A vaporizer. Right? Gotta say that that sounds cool.

Chuck Nice
Did you hear that? That's what an estimated 500 hp sounds like. XCO give it to you? How about that? That's a premium banging Olufsen sound system with 18 speakers and a biosonic sound experience.

Acura wins. Fletota that. That's our legacy. You ready to be a part of it? Unlock the energy of the all electric CDX type s?

Order now@acura.com. Dot do you want to set up your child for success? Of course you do. Maybe you want to save money on private tutoring, or maybe it's just out of your budget altogether. Is this a big school year for your child?

Rosetta Stone
Like, maybe they're starting kindergarten, middle school, or high school, or some other milestone. Maybe your family moved and they're starting at a new school. Is your child ahead not getting challenged enough in class? Well, we love that little smarty, but we want them to be engaged. Ixl Learning is an online learning program for kids covering math, language arts, science, and social studies.

IXL is designed to help them really understand and master topics in a fun way. Powered by advanced algorithms, Ixl gives the right help to each kid, no matter the age or the personality. There is one site for all the kids in your home. Pre k to 12th grade kids can use it at home, on the computer or on the go through the app, on your phone or your tablet. No more grading those worksheets.

I excel grades everything itself. And no more trying to figure out how to explain math equations or grammar rules yourself. IXL has built in explanation videos. One in four students in the US are learning with IxL. IXL is used in 95 of the top 100 school districts in the US.

Make an impact on your child's learning. Get Ixl now and startalk radio listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today@ixl.com. Startalk. Visit ixl.com startalk to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. Start clean with Clorox.

Because Clorox delivers a powerful clean every time. Because messes happen. Because, hey, listen, remember how you told me to toss those takeout containers before we. And you were like, I'm serious. If that leaks over the counter, it'll be a slimy abomination by the time I get back.

Chuck Nice
And I was like, yeah, yeah, yeah, of course. Don't worry about it. I won't forget. Well. Oh, yeah, that happens.

So start clean with Clorox. Use Clorox products as directed. Rinse after use if in contact with food service.

Chuck Nice
Uh, here we go. What degree can you do more with, a physics degree or a mathematics degree? Physics degree. Really? Yeah.

Rosetta Stone
Now are you biased? Some things are objectively true in the world.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Let's say it another way. In spite of what it might seem like to your parents, if you choose to major in physics or math, both of them are highly employable by people who know and understand the brain wiring that emerges for having done so. Absolutely. Okay. Yes.

Mathematicians and physicists are problem solvers, and engineers are problem solvers. They can see problems in ways others have not. And it's just that physics has more places to plug into more operations of society than does a mathematician, that's all. But in either case, you don't see either mathematicians or physicists as on the street, begging. Begging.

Chuck Nice
Right, right. Exactly. You'll find artists, you'll find musicians. We'll calculate for food. That's right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
We'll recite digits of pie. Right? No, no. So pie for pie. Haven't had pie all day.

How many digits can you do? So it's a reminder that there's certain professions that fundamentally plug in to civilization and others that become a part of civilization because we choose it to. So we embrace music, we embrace art, the kind of art that is not otherwise self sufficient. So I'm not talking about pop music. I'm talking about orchestral music that generally is performed in institutions that require funding.

Funding, yes. And that funding normally comes from someone who gives a great deal of money to make that happen. Correct. Because it can't sustain itself. It doesn't sustain itself through the appetite of the public.

Yet the city in which you find those offerings of art boasts that they have those offerings of art. Right. It's in the catalog. We have this Philharmonic hall of Austin Philharmonic, and we have this art museum, and we have all these institutions. That's what makes us a cosmopolitan destination.

Correct. So it's an interesting difference that we have art and science in the same phrase. I went to the College of Arts and Sciences at the University of whatever. Arts and sciences go way back. As a paired thing, we have Leonardo as the epitome.

Chuck Nice
Right. Actually combining the two in the. Combining two. He's one of the greatest examples of that. So I'm just saying, a society has to want to embrace its artists in order for them to manifest as a fully expressed employed community.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Whereas financial forces can drive your interest in having an engineer or a physicist on staff. Absolutely. For example, Mayor Bloomberg. Yes. Former mayor Bloomberg.

Chuck Nice
Yes. Okay. Successful businessman. Very much so. Very much so.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Billionaire, multibillionaire. Like a real billionaire. Not like some other people. Is that some other people you earned as. I'm very rich.

Chuck Nice
Very, very rich. Normally, when people tell you they're very rich, they're me. They ain't, right. They're me. Like, yo, don't look at that.

I'm very rich. So here's the thing. When he built this company, right, he could have hired mbas who know their business, but that's not who he hired. Could he hire. He majored in physics and engineering at Johns Hopkins University.

Okay. He hired mathematicians, physicists, and engineers. Wow. And would teach them the business side of the world. But he needed people who.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Problem solvers who would go with gnashed teeth and attack a problem they've never seen before. Right, right. And my wife was one of those earliest employees. Get out. She has a PhD in mathematical law.

Chuck Nice
Because I knew that. I didn't know that she worked for Bloomberg in the early days. Yes. When she was there, Bloomberg had 100 employees. Oh, my God.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Yeah. She got more money than you now. I know.

So she was early in on that, and he recognized what she could bring to the table there. Interesting. As others that she worked with. Yeah. That's so cool.

Chuck Nice
Yeah. Yeah. All right, so go for it. Go, go. Either.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Do either. If you're gonna pick one of those, pick the one you love and do it. And do it. Okay, cool. And you'll be better at it than others.

And people beat a path to your door. All right, give me some more. Okay, here we go. Why haven't there been a greater number of advancements on solar energy, given it's literally a constant, free source of energy? Yeah, the source of the energy is free, but the devices to convert it into useful forms, given the economics of what is going on right now, has not yet reached that tipping point.

So right now, sort of the wealthy class that has the luxury of being green without regard to its impact on your pocketbook. They're the first adopters of the electric cars and the electric this and the solar panels and the like. What is missing from the equation is how much our tax money throughout the last century has subsidized the oil and gas industry. There you go. Okay.

We built the roads, bought the car that now, we put their gas in the. They didn't build the roads. That's right. Okay, so the question is, can and should society subsidize the solar energy universe in the way we have subsidized all the rest of the fossil fuels industry? And in doing so, would that tip the economics in the favor of solar panels and solar energy?

Chuck Nice
That's a great point, man. Yeah. By the way, that was George Xenofontos. Who actually love that. Xenophontos.

Oh, man. And by the way. Yeah. Getting a tan is free. Solar power is not.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Yeah. So the sun's energy is basically limitless. But also you have to be able to transport energy, move it from where it is to where you need it. And solar power exists when the sun is out and it's daytime. So where you're getting your energy at night, you gotta be able to store energy.

Yeah. So battery technology is still a century behind other technologies. So there's still some. But wouldn't you see a proliferation of new battery designs and an improvement in battery life if you were to see the same burgeoning of solar power? I think one would drive the other.

Possibly. Except we already have a huge demand for. We're using more batteries today than ever before. This is true. It used to be I need a battery for my motor car.

And so you go buy the battery, and then the battery would leak or run out, or you leave it on. The buying of batteries was a major thing in the day. Now anybody's house has 30 batteries laying around. That's true. Okay.

And the batteries last longer than ever. And our machines, our devices that use. Batteries, use them more efficiently. Use them more efficiently. Exactly.

So batteries, we think batteries are improving at a higher rate than they actually are because the demand, the energy demand is demand for even our flashlights are leds. Exactly. Which means that they're using much less juice. Yeah, exactly. Wow.

Chuck Nice
Okay. Well, listen, man, I can only hope that. George, that what you want to see actually happen. Yeah. Yeah.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
And so, like I said, it's an economics thing, right? So the day that economics tips, everybody will have solar panels on every horizontal surface in their life. It'll happen practically overnight. Cause that's how these things work. And in a free society, there's a limit to how much you can beat someone on the head to get them to spend more money for something that's almost as good or not quite as good as what they already have.

Chuck Nice
Right. Or even if it's a little better, but if they can do it cheaper. So most people wanna save the buck. That's true. That's.

Yep. That's why I don't mind that right now. You can't give away an incandescent bulb. No, you can't. You can't, because they cost you more money if you're smart enough to know what you have.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
No, no, no. So, incandescent bulbs. No, I think they're cheaper than a thing, but if you do, it costs you more money. They ultimately cost you more money, and you gotta throw them away and they get hot, everything. Well, they're really a heat source, not a light source.

Chuck Nice
Correct. They give it more infrared than they do visible light. That's correct. Yeah. I learned that from you.

I'm just. That's how long we've been working together. They're primarily a heat source. Yeah. They're primarily a heat source.

Yeah. Right. All right, here we go. Marco Blackwell from Facebook wants to know this. With the advancements of science, has there been any attempts to change any of the established rules, laws of physics, laws of motion, thermodynamics, et cetera?

Or is it, once that it's a law and it's established that it just cannot be changed? So, in other words, you were like 10% Captain Kirk on that one. I know. It just cannot be changed. Tell me, Spock, what is it with the laws of thermodynamics?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Once. Once. Okay. In the old days, we used to call them laws back in the 19th century, classical. The pinnacles of classical physics.

Newton's laws of motion, the laws of thermodynamics. 20th century, we've loosened the word law. We don't use the word law anymore. Not because they aren't laws. Right.

Just because we're a little more candid about the fact that what we say is a fundamental property of the universe may be a small part of a bigger understanding of the universe. Exactly. Whereas law implies. Here we go. But what we are discovering that is experimentally verified is not later shown to be false.

And this is a misconception that so many people have. They say, oh, there's a theory of quantum theory. That means that we won't be different. No, it is working, baby. Right.

We got this. Okay. There's still some other things we can understand about it. There's still some frontiers. It may plug into a larger understanding.

But the quantum theory that we have established, experimented on, and works, we are good to go. So, no, it does not change. It only expands. There's the rub. Yeah, exactly.

Chuck Nice
Expands. Our understanding can expand on that understanding, but it doesn't swap out that understanding once it has been experimentally verified. At that point, it elevates to the level of theory. So that's why I'm trying. I may lose this battle, but I'm trying to get people to not say when they say, I have a theory about.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
No, you have a hypothesis. Right. Okay. And it's probably not even a hypothesis. You have a feeling, right?

Chuck Nice
Right. Theory. No, Einstein had a theory. Exactly. Because the hypothesis, if you have a feeling, that's another.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
That's another level. I got a feeling. I got a feeling because people say, I have a hypothesis, and I'm like, really? Is it educated? Have you really thought it through?

Chuck Nice
Because that. Yeah. Okay, we got two minutes left. How many? What do you got?

All right, here's one. This is Haney. Laugh in advance of the question. That's embarrassing for the person who asked the question. I'm not laughing at the question.

I'm just laughing. Okay. I'm laughing. Laughing at the question. Haney Lawrence says this from where?

From Instagram. Okay, what causes thunder? Thunder. Very good. I know, but it just seems so weird to ask Neil degrasse Tyson.

What, because you're an astrophysicist there. Physics, dude. It is physics. But I'm just saying there's so much that you are associated with in terms of your expertise. Maybe this person knows everything else and it's the only gap left in their knowledge.

Oh, sure. So. Yeah. Right? Yeah.

They know all about red shifting, but they don't know what thunder is. Okay. Okay. By the way, I am not trying to disparage you, Lauren, at all. Okay?

All right. I mean, Haney. And that's his name. Haney. All right, so what is thunder?

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Here you go. Okay, so during a thunderstorm. Yes. A rainstorm. A vigorous rainstorm, water falls out of the clouds, and generally those water droplets have a net charge associated with them.

A net negative charge. Okay. So it is separating negative charges out of the cloud and putting it in the ground. All right? There's a limit to how much of that you can get away with before the charges say, we want to rebalance.

Chuck Nice
We need more charge. No, we want to un. We want to uncharge. Uncharge. Right.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Okay. You are stripping negatives from positives, and that's not how they want to be. Right. Okay. They want to be balanced.

They want to be balanced. So this builds up enough imbalance and it says, I'm coming back to you, Elizabeth. Elizabeth, I'm coming to join you, honey. I'm coming back. I'm going to Untar.

Okay, so those charges rise up, right? And they come out of the ground, and they create a visible arc of light that we call lightning back up to the cloud. Okay, so all lightning, cloud to cloud or ground to cloud, right? It's not cloud to ground. All visible lightning.

Okay, so up comes this. This very hot, extremely hot arc of light. Arc of light. Okay. It is so hot that when you.

Chuck Nice
Open and look into it, your face melts. It's beautiful.

Okay. Oh, God, we are such nerds. Such raiders nerds here. Okay, so it's so hot. It is so hot that the air.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
The air catastrophically expands. Interesting. That's what happens in the cartridge of a bullet, right? It gets hot. That's why it makes a bang.

And so. And it expands catastrophically. The bullet comes out the side, the shell drops to the ground. Right? Okay, so anytime you rapidly expand, rapidly heat air.

That's how a bomb works. It rapidly heats air. That's how the nuclear bombs work. You rapidly heat the air. The air knows only to expand catastrophically at that point.

And it's a shockwave, a shock wave. So it's not just, I'm getting louder. No, it's boom. Right? And it's that expanding air that you then hear as thunder.

Chuck Nice
After the lightning. After the lightning. And it moves at the speed of. Sound, which means the lightning you always see first. Okay, so I forgot.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Was it 7 seconds a mile or something? Some number of seconds per mile. So you can count how far away the lightning is and how far away that thunderclap was from you. And that lets you know how close. The storm is by the time delays.

I saw a documentary once, and he's very concerned about the accuracy of the thing. And he had a thunderstorm out in the distance. And you heard the lightning. Exactly. With the thunder.

So at the end, the filmmaker was there in the room. I said, why did I hear the thunder exactly timed with the lightning? I first said, do you care about accuracy in your documentary? Of course. Of course.

Accuracy is everything. So I said, why did the light. Oh, well, we shifted the sound because it was too weird. It's too weird to watch them. It looks like it's out of sync.

Chuck Nice
That's because it is out of sync. Nature made it out of sync. You know what's really cool? If you go see a shuttle launch, go back in time, I was gonna say, or watch any launch. Any launch.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Any launch. That's a catastrophic heating of the air. It's thunderous, and the closest you can get if you're a civilian is like 3 miles away. So you just see this thing take off and it's total silence. It's total silence.

And you see the shockwave, the front wave of the sound move. This is Florida, so there's a lot of water around. Yeah. So you see this ripple moving towards you and birds coming up. You still don't hear anything.

It's still sounding. Then you hear as it comes you. So it's just fun to watch the sound come to you. Nice. It's just a fun thing to do that.

But anyhow, so that's what thunder is. And because the arc is not a straight line, it can bend. It'll take the most electrically expedient way back to the cloud. Makes sense. And it's not always a straight line.

It could be because it's wetter here and water absorbs, conducts electricity better than dry air does. Okay, so what you have here is if there's angles to the lightning strike, it's possible for you to be at the focus of two of those angles. So in other words, if there's a straight segment off to your right and a straight segment off to your left, then you have sound coming to you from two different directions. Ooh. And if they hit you at the same time, you get the snap, that crack of the thunder, like it sounds.

Chuck Nice
Like a paper tearing or the sky is tearing. It's an extra magnification of the sound because you get multiple sound paths coming to you at the same time. Oh, I love it. Rather than just one one. It's like, yeah, that's this, that, that.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
All these different angles coming to you at different times, some of them hitting you at the same time. Cool, Chuck, we gotta end it there. Oh, man. That was a good one, dude. Always good to have you, man.

Chuck Nice
It's always gonna be here. Love you, man. Love you too, man. Love you, Chuck. Love you, Chuck.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
You've been listening to possibly even watching startalk. I'm Neil degrasse Tyson. You're a personal astrophysicist, and this brings an end to our physics of everyday life. Cosmic queries. As always, I bid you to keep looking up.

Some people think Taco Bell is only for late night, but if that was the case, it wouldn't be open all day. That'd be horrible, man. It's also for daytime, which is why Taco Bell's introducing the new cantina chicken menu with new cantina chicken tacos, burrito and quesadilla with seasoned slow roasted chicken. And even a new avocado verde salsa packet. You should try it today, emphasizing that word so you don't forget that it's not just for late night.

Neil deGrasse Tyson
Introducing the new cantina chicken menu. Taco Bell at participating us Taco Bell. Locations while supplies last. Contact store for participation witch fares.

Chuck Nice
Did you hear that? That's what an estimated 500 hp sounds like. XCO give it to you. How about that? That's a premium banging Olufsen sound system with 18 speakers and a biosonic sound experience.

That's our legacy. You ready to be a part of it? Xcom give it to you. Unlock the energy of the all electric CDX type S. Order now@acura.com.

Cosmic Queries - Physics All Around Us

Primary Topic

Episode Summary

Main Takeaways

Episode Chapters

1: Introduction to Everyday Physics

2: Deep Dive into Physical Laws

3: Interdisciplinary Connections

4: Practical Applications

Actionable Advice

About This Episode

People

Content Warnings:

Transcript